Any Certified umpire who is assigned with a Non-Certified umpire on a JV or Freshman game is expected to turn in an Observation/Evaluation Report.

It is our philosophy to cultivate softball umpires through positive reinforcemant, encouragement, and suggestions for ways to improve.
Arizona Region I Softball Umpires
Observation/Evaluation Form
Umpire who was observed
Position PlateBases
Game (Teams)
Date of Game
Observer's Name
Observer's E-mail
Observation/Evaluation
Appearance Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Game Management Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Attitude/Professionalism Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Signals Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Plate Mechanics Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Base Mechanics Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Hustle/Briskness Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
Rules Knowledge Needs ImprovementSatisfactory Good Superior
I talked with the umpire after observing YesNo
What is your "Gut" feel. Please elaborate.